IASTEM INTERNATIONAL CONFERENCE
Tokyo, Japan 24-10-2026
2 papers
-
Strengthening Public Governance of Organic Production and Circulation: A Functional Comparison of Kazakhstan and Japan
Umbetbayeva Zhuldyz Baimuratkyzy, Rasheva Gulnur Koishynovna
Paper ID ICMRME-TOKY-241026-108 · Pages 1-18
Download PDF: Strengthening Public Governance of Organic Production and Circulation: A Functional Comparison of Kazakhstan and JapanAbstract
The status of organic products relies on consumer trust. This is because, now of purchase, a buyer cannot independently verify that prohibited substances were avoided during production, that transition period requirements were fully met, or that supply chain data is accurate. Consequently, the primary legal issue in the organic production sector extends beyond merely defining the concept itself; it is equally important to establish an effective control and guarantee system that fosters public and consumer confidence without imposing an excessive financial burden on producers. This article compares the practices of organic product production and circulation regulation in Kazakhstan and Japan, examining which Japanese mechanisms could be applied during the implementation of reforms in Kazakhstan scheduled for 2024–2026. The study employs doctrinal-legal and functional comparative-legal analysis methods. It examines key legislative acts, implementing regulations, standards, accreditation and certification procedures, state policy documents, and international recommendations. The analysis covered eight areas: institutional mandates, production standards, conformity assessment, protection of organic product labeling, traceability, market surveillance, international recognition, and regional support. The study revealed that, rather than a simple hierarchy where one country's system is superior to the other, the two systems possess distinct structural characteristics. A hybrid model is emerging in Kazakhstan that combines accredited certification, Participatory Guarantee Systems (PGS), group certification mechanisms, a producer registry, product traceability requirements, and measures to subsidize certification costs. In contrast, Japan relies primarily on the certification-based Organic JAS system. In this system, the protection of organic product labeling, inspection and oversight, enforcement measures for non-compliance, equivalence mechanisms, and regional support initiatives are more precisely coordinated with one another. The article concludes that Kazakhstan needs to strengthen the linkages between certification status, state registries, market surveillance, consumer information, and export recognition, while retaining the accessible and flexible mechanisms of the current system. The proposed model aims to simultaneously ensure the credibility and accessibility of the organic sector. It envisions enhancing data consistency regarding certification status, implementing risk-based controls, presenting information on the organic control system in an understandable manner, standardizing reporting by certification bodies, developing regional organic development plans, and preparing for international equivalence in a phased manner. Keywords - Organic Products; Public Governance; Comparative Law; Kazakhstan; Japan; Organic Jas; Participatory Guarantee Systems; Traceability; Equivalence; Legal Transplantation.
-
From Certification to Policy Coherence : Integrating Investment, Land, Environmental, Tax, and Customs Mechanisms for Organic Production in Kazakhstan
Zhanna Kalymbekova, Aizhan Moldagaliyeva
Paper ID ICMRME-TOKY-241026-109 · Pages 19-31
Download PDF: From Certification to Policy Coherence : Integrating Investment, Land, Environmental, Tax, and Customs Mechanisms for Organic Production in KazakhstanAbstract
Kazakhstan's 2024 reform substantially strengthened the legal recognition and verification of organic production, but the economic consequences of that status remain dispersed across investment, land, environmental, tax, and customs law. This article examines whether those adjacent regimes operate as a coherent policy system across the organic production lifecycle. The study combines doctrinal legal analysis, functional comparison, and structured qualitative coding of legislation and policy instruments in force as of September 2026. To make cross-sectoral gaps visible, it applies a five-dimension Cross-Code Functional Integration Index (CFII): explicit recognition of organic status, existence of a dedicated operational instrument, lifecycle alignment, use of verified status as a legal trigger, and digital interoperability. The score is used as a diagnostic device rather than as a measure of institutional quality. The results show a pronounced imbalance. Organic/agricultural support is comparatively well integrated through the producer register and certification-cost subsidy, whereas investment, land, environmental, and tax regimes largely operate in parallel; customs/trade has stronger digital potential but no systematic organic-status interface. Comparison with the European Union and Japan indicates that effective organic policy is built through a portfolio of stage-specific measures rather than through certification support alone. The article proposes an evidence-bridge architecture in which verified organic data can be reused, for defined purposes, by other public authorities while substantive decisions remain within the relevant sectoral laws. Policy implications include an organic-transition investment window, plot-linked status data, results-based agro-environmental support, temporary treatment of documented transition costs, and electronic certificate verification for customs and export procedures, all subject to fiscal, environmental, competition, data-governance, and trade safeguards. Keywords - Organic Production; Policy Coherence; Investment Law; Land Law; Environmental Regulation; Taxation; Customs; Kazakhstan; Regulatory Integration; Sustainable Agriculture.